Total Pageviews

Monday, December 3, 2012

The Woman Who Fell From the Sky

Which character was more important to the birth of the Earth, Flint or Sapling?  Why? Use your own thoughts and defend your claim with proof.

27 comments:

The Whatever Girl said...

I think that Flint was a more important character because even though he was more of the villain than the hero, he gives us humans strength. This is true because as humans, Flint tried to make harder for us, and because of him, we are able to face the hardships we go through, mostly because of him. In my perspective, Sapling made life easier for us, but without Flint, life wouldn't be what it is today, and it would be too easy. Even though an easier life wouldn't be bad, we need to understand that hardships must be faced and we couldn't depend on people like Sapling to be there for us at every corner. This may lead people to believe that Flint actually put bones in fish and tried to make life more difficult so we could become wiser and learn to face the hardships that is experienced in the world everyday. Although Sapling helped humans, I believe that Sapling thought we wouldn't be able to face hardships and was trying to make life easier. However useful that may seem, Flint is also giving us wisdom, which is why I think Flint is more important.

Unknown said...

Tazrean, do you really think that the world would become a better place if all people were like Flint? All though since Sapling really was a more of nature person(nurture versus nature) because he wasn't naturally born as a kind hearted person ; he got the personality from his mother. The same with Flint because he got his heart feelings from his father. I mostly think that Sapling was more important to the birth of the Earth because if all people in the world were like him, we would all face the same prospective and adversity. Some people like Flint teach us in the world that evil is sometimes better than the good because there are many things that we have to face during life though its sometimes part of religion. I also think that both characters are important to the birth of the birth of the Earth because something caused by Flint happens to be an external problem of Sapling. We have hell and heaven for a reason because we all spent our things in either two directions. We all have different prospective of who we are that can't change ourselves.

Alvy6132 said...

I concur with Tazrean because it is true that if it wasn't for Flint we would live in a too easy world. We need the world to be tough too because you never know that if something bad happened then it would be so difficult for us to solve it. We need to be prepared for the hard things in our life. Flint was bad but he showed that life was tough and prepared us if anything bad happened then we would be prepared for it. Maybe Sapling wouldn't be prepared for the bad that might happen to him if he is trying to make the world perfect. If anything happened to him then he wouldn't be able to protect himself. So Flint taught that living a hard life is bad but we will always be prepared for it no matter what. So Flint is important. Alvy.

Alvy6132 said...

Actually Lamiya life would have been easy with Sapling. Flint taught us to be ready for bad. Sapling though would make the world a better place but then we would be at home doing nothing but sitting then we would have no purpose to do nothing so Flint must be more important. He taught us to be ready for anything bad or dangerous. Alvy.

Unknown said...

Flint because without earth would be too good, and everybody would be spoiled. They would also be lazy. They wouldn't really have to do any work at all.Sapling is also good to be born because if he wasn't alive we would be eaten by monsters ( dinosaurs) I wonder what would happen if they werent born! I can make a connection, in my religion Adam had 2 sons. Habil and Kabil. I think Habil was the good one and kabil was the bad one but anyway, Habil always did better thats why kabil was evil, he was jealous. So one day he was into evil he killed his brother and then he realized what he did and he didn't know what to do.Like with the hole. He saw a bird burying a dead bird, s he did the same. Another connection is that in spongeob, spongebob found a pencil and drew himself. It came to life, but the brain was evil unlike spongebob. They defeated it by erasing it.

Unknown said...

I think that Flint was WAY by far more important. This is because he taught us about discipline. Discipline is important and without it you could not be successful in life. Also without hardships such as snow we would die of warmness. Winter is cold and if summer was all day long and life would be hot people would die of heartburn. Also he gave us bones and without those I would not be typing and just this chunk of meat which can't move. It is just that Flint's intention was bad, not his actions.

F.A.N said...

Laymia, You have to know. Sapling made everything easy for us humans so life would be easy. We wouldnt learn everything. Its like in class waht i think we talked about um iforgot but Obstacles are supposed to be on our way so we could learn and jump over those difficult obstacles.I rest.

F.A.N said...

Laymia,You have to know. Sapling made everything easy for us humans so life would be easy. We wouldnt learn everything. Its like in class waht i think we talked about um iforgot but Obstacles are supposed to be on our way so we could learn and jump over those difficult obstacles. Live would be to easy. No knowlege means you wouldnt be wearing clothe you are wearing right now. Also humans would not know anything. They learn about fish and bones from flint and Sapling. Sapling made it easy but didnt think about how easy he made life. Flint didnt either but it turnd out right. COLLEGE< SCHOOL< STUDY< ETC. ~FAHIM

Unknown said...

I think Flint was a more important character because he gives the people on earth challenges and doesn't cradle everyone and let them a easy peasy life. So, what I'm saying is that I think Flint is most important to the world because he gives challenges to the world and not all, answers and a care free life.

Unknown said...

Lamiya, if Flint wasn't born, there would not have been animals in earth, and if there were no animals, then just imagine the world how it would be now. There would be so many dead people now, because thee would not be any animals living, and without animals, there would not be food or (now going to science) there wont be so much decomposers, and no decomposers means no photo synthesis and then there wont be any oxygen for people to breath. Life would be horrible if flint was not born.
©2012 ≈Nur Rohan §ìddíqüê

Unknown said...

There might be a lot of spelling mistakes because I am typing on a kindle fire :D

Anonymous said...

I concur with Tazrean because imagine world so easy that if the bad monsters ever come out,(dinosaurs and monsers from greek mythlogy) we wouldn't be ready for the task before hand. Also, people would probably faint at the sight of the monsters. People are primates and that's why people are so smart, since we have a small portion of saplings brain. These hard tasks will allow us to work to our limits and realize what we are capable of. This is why I think flint is better than sapling.

F.A.N said...

Rohan remember that sapling put them under ground

Ammaaazing Asian said...

Flint is more important because he makes life hard for people so life is a struggle for people but it teachs people to know more because snow is a challege so people learn from everything.Without bones the natives wouldn't be able to do many things. Thanks to Flint we have many resources.

Afm Khan said...

Flint is way more important than Sapling. I think this because Flint is who made our lives worth it by giving us cunning and the sense of danger. If it weren't for Flint, Christopher Colombud would never have had the bravery to go and discover America. I also concur with Shayan because Flint made our lives have discipline, which sounds like a bad thing but is actually a good thing. In final analysis, Flint is way more important than Sapling. I think this because Flint is who made our lives worth it

Crossides said...

I think that Flint is more important because he isn't only making things harder for people, he is also trying to make the people who would come to the earth more skillful. For example, people can't be lazy all their lives. So that is why Flint put bones in the fish. Life can never be so easy. It might make things hard. But that is how everything is. In addition, a lazy world wouldn't be as fun at it is now. Flint is just trying to make us wiser. Sapling might have made things easier but thing aren't always that way. I concur with Tazrean when she says,"Flint is also giving us wisdom" and "... without Flint, life wouldn't be what it is today."

The Whatever Girl said...

Lamiya, as everyone else said, Sapling isn't that important because if everyone was like him, kind and helpful, maybe the world would have been better. But then everyone wouldn't be facing life for what it is, meaning they wouldn't be in the reality of life, which isn't some kind and helpful world. Flint, however, wasn't as evil and horrible as we all think. The point of view of the author made us think Flint was a villain, but he's really not. As you said Lamiya, we have to face life and Flint teaches us that.

Unknown said...

I can concour with tazrean when you said Flint teaches us to face life.To prove this thought in the story it says that Sapling put fish into the rivers ,but Flint put bones into the fish and made the rivers flow one way so thatit wasn't so easy for the people soon to come.Spling was very important because he created everything,but without Flint we would not be living the way we are with challengesin life.

Unknown said...

I used to think that Sapling was important to the birth of the Earth but now I think that Flint is important to the Earth because he teaches us the importance of life. Yes, if there were people that were like Flint and Sapling the world be beneficial to us because there is a chance that we are going to face our life in two different ways. Flint is more important to our world because if all people were as goody -goody as Sapling there would be nothing to face in our life. Today we would be in perfect shape of Sapling but it won't do any good to us because we won't know what really is the way how a life works. This is why I think that Flint is more important to the birth of the Earth.

Afsana Akter said...

I think Flint was more important because he created the difficulties of mankind. We 'wouldn't' be struggling right now without him. He kind of taught us lessons, showed that we can get everything our way, etc. In the book, when Sapling created fish, Flint added bones, which I take as learning to be careful. When Flint created monsters, he created terrors. I also agree with the comment above mine( sorry, counts as a spelling error, and I cant post comments with errors),that Flint showed the importance of life.

Unknown said...

I concur with you, Lamiya, because if it weren't for Flint we wouldn't know how to face life; even the slightest problem would make us go crazy. To add on, I believe that in these very problem that Flint create, there is a bright side; that is why people say, When life gives you lemons, make lemonade.
~Angel

Unknown said...

I think that Flint was more important to the birth of earth because Flint started the problems and with that Sapling makes something that is beneficial for the people. Sapling cleans up Flint's messes and turns them into something to help others.

~Erika Amaro

F.A.N said...

.

Afm Khan said...

I beg to differ with your thoughts Lamiya because would it really be good if there were no crimes, no bad things? What about if we made no mistakes? Mankind needs to make mistakes and like Flint, the mistakes might be bad so Flint is more important because he taught us about making mistakes and about discipline, like Shayan said.
~ Afm Khan

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

i think that flint is more important because he gives the challenges in life and all that sapling does is make life easier for the humans but if we had easy lives and a problem showed up then we wouldnt know how to handle it because we would have such a easy life

Afm Khan said...

Hello everybody. I know that we all are debating over who is actually better: Flint or Sapling but shouldn't we even try to realize that both of them are important because Flint has helped all of us realize that discipline is important but I guess we also have to realize that Sapling has helped us learn to be kind to others and to always be nice and that when you are nice to somebody, they will also be nice to you.

~Pokémon Master Afm Khan